Skip to main content

Jonathan Stephenson of Cayton England and Crawford County Iowa

My great grandfather was Jonathan Stephenson - my mother's paternal grandfather, although she would never have the chance to know him. He died a few months before she was born, at the same home in fact while visiting in Castana, Iowa in 1919.

He was born in Cayton, England, a village just south of Scarborough, Yorkshire, in 1847. His father, George, was a grocer, dairyman, and small farmer. His family had been in the Cayton area for centuries. Jonathan's mother was Mary Bielby from Bridlington, a larger town farther down the coast to the south.

Jonathan and his older brother, Robert, weren't listed with their parents, sister, Jane, and younger brother, Henry, in the 1861 census. Robert had died a few years earlier, and since Jonathan was almost 14, he probably had to go to work. Yet another brother, John Robert, was born in 1862.A couple years later, Jonathan's mother died and his father remarried, to Ann Harrison in 1866  and started another family. Jonathan would have known his two half-sisters, Mary "Elizabeth" and Charlotte Ellen, as infants.
Jonathan Stephenson around 1900

It was probably 1871 or so that Jonathan immigrated to the U.S. I was told that he moved to Indiana and lost his wife in childbirth. He did confirm in the 1915 census that he had been in the U.S. 9 years before going to Iowa.

I think it was unusual for people to move to a new country without having had some acquaintance already there. In doing research on Ancestry, I found a DNA match to  Stephenson family with roots in Pike County, Indiana. In her tree, she has a Jonathan Stephenson born 1815 in England. Given the close match, I believe her Jonathan Stephenson was my Jonathan's uncle, brother to my Jonathan's father, George. Another uncle, Robinson Stephenson, went to Pike County Indiana as well. I suspect my Jonathan might have followed his uncles there. And to make matters interesting, in Pike county Indiana in 1871, a Jonathan Stephenson married Lealla Smith. I think this might be his first marriage, but still a bit of a question.

The first time I can find Jonathan Stephenson documented in the U.S. for certain is when he marries Lillian Davis in 1881 at Dunlap. Both Jonathan, and Lillian's father, William Davis, were workers on the railroad around this time, so perhaps that brought them together. Jonathon was only six years younger than his father-in-law. Lillian Davis was born in Galesburg, Illinois, roughly between Pike County, Indiana and Dow City, Iowa. Galesburg was a mecca for the expanding railroad industry and perhaps drew both Jonathan and his eventual father-in-law.

Jonathan and Lillian had a large family in Paradise Township of Crawford County, Iowa, five boys and three girls.
Jonathan Stephenson with grandson Gerald Stephenson Turner about 1917

Jonathan probably made a couple trips back to England. The Denison review published an article December 17, 1897 that he went to England, to return by March. And, he wanted to take his grandson, Gerald, back with him on a later trip, but was talked out of it. He had a lot of family back there, although his parents were both gone. His sister, Jane Rex, had a large family. He had a younger brother, Henry, and his family, and two much younger half-sisters, Charlotte and Elizabeth, who he probably remembered as babies.

Most likely, the reason for his 1897 trip, was the death of his stepmother, Ann Harrison Stephenson. She had died in October of that year. Family tradition has it that he went back to England to get an inheritance but there was none. Jonathon perhaps had hoped to get some of his father's inheritance, but no doubt the stepmother didn't remember her deceased husband's previous children in her will.

Ann Stephenson and her unmarried daughter, Elizabeth, were big news in Yorkshire in 1884. Elizabeth's baby had died under mysterious circumstances. The coroner had planned to examine the body, but Ann and Elizabeth decided to dispose of the body in their fireplace. Of course this raised a lot of eyebrows, and at first brought murder charges against them. Eventually they were found guilty of lesser charges and each served two months in jail.

Family was important to Jonathan. He had a big family here. The Denison Review reported that he held an ice cream party until the "wee small hours of the morning" on August 13, 1911.

His obituary had good words about him.


When I read the words "lover of home", "devoted to family", "respected pioneer", and "good, kind neighbor", I think of all he had overcome. He lost much of his family, including two young brothers and his mother when he was a young man, and likely an earlier wife and child. His childhood was short as he started to work as a boy. He left his home to come to America. But he persisted, he pioneered, he built a new home and a new family, and I am proud to be part of that family.





Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Where Did That Dark Complexion Come From?

When I got my DNA results back, the biggest surprise I had was in all the people from the southern states who I shared DNA with. I'm pretty sure that a lot of it is from Salucia Sophronia Squibb , but that certainly doesn't explain it all. The only other unknown line, is that of Martha Brennan Davis , mother of Lillian Davis Stephenson, who was mother of my grandfather, Fred Stephenson. I have thought she was Irish, probably an Irish immigrant, and probably related to other Brennans of Galesburg, Illinois, but there is evidence she was from Indiana. Besides the unexplained southern DNA matches, I have little Irish DNA on this line, not enough for Martha Brennan to be full blooded Irish. But more importantly, the Stephensons had dark complexions. I honestly don't know beyond that where the dark hair and eyes came from. Here is a picture of Lillian Davis Stephenson, my great grandmother. Notice the dark hair, deep set, dark eyes. She doesn't look Irish. Her featur...

The Twenty Children of David Brady - updated 2024

This was originally published December 15, 2014. It was updated in 2021 to provide more information on David Brady's children and a fourth wife. In 2024, information on David Brady's wives, Fanny Cornell and Abigail Filley, David's will, and other details, were added. David Brady, born 1785 in Sussex County, New Jersey, died on his homestead, west of Cassopolis, Michigan, in 1878. He is buried on his farm where he and his family first camped upon claiming his land in 1829. Page 229 of the History of Cass County, Michigan  says that he was married several times and reared a very large family of children, over twenty, of whom however only one, Mrs Phebe Merwin, is now living in La Grange. His widow married Thomas Moore and is a resident of this township. That's quite the statement. Over twenty children. Married several times. Tough to prove, though. David's will goes a long way to clear it all up. Records from the frontier are pretty scarce, and in that time period ...

John Griest - A Pennsylvania Pioneer

On my mother's side, is an ancestor named John Griest. He lived in Pennsylvania from 1694 to 1751. John's daughter, Sarah, married William Squibb. While most of us will leave no evidence of our existence, John Griest did leave a few things to remember him by. Probably most significant is the office building at the Susquehanna Memorial Gardens near York, Pennsylvania. This building was originally larger, and at another location in York. This beautiful picture was taken by Diane Bowders and published on Yorkblog.com. John Griest built this building around 1740 at its original location on what is now the Lincoln Highway in York. In 1962 it was taken down to make way for a shopping mall and rebuilt at the cemetery. At that time the building looked something like this: The sturdy building was known as Ye Olde Valley Inn, Beard's Inn, etc. and was originally built to protect John's family from Indians, with whom he didn't always have the best relationship. Gries...